Florida Governor Ron DeSantis signed into law last week whathe called“the unattackable piece of legislation that ’s been enacted anywhere in the country ” against COVID-19 vaccine mandatory . Businesses that violate the jurisprudence by requiring worker to be immunise without earmark exemptions face fines of up to $ 50,000 .

The Sunshine State is now the first in the US with such a law place secret businesses , and yes , even hospitals , that introduce vaccinum mandates for doer . And for no particular reason at all , let ’s just think that DeSantis fight back President Biden’sfederal vaccinum mandateback in Septemberspecificallyon the footing that issuing such order to business and person was “ essentially untimely ” and “ coercive ” , say that “ endanger mandates and firing off and business upshot … estrange [ people ] . ”

Floridian wishing to work without get the incrediblyeffectiveandsafevaccines have a few options : they can apply for a aesculapian or religious exemption ( and hope their employer does n’t require them toswear off the Tylenol as well ) or agree to undergo regular examination for COVID-19 transmission – a get - out clause that was actually include in President Biden ’s original vaccine mandate back in September .

But there ’s another alternative – one that DeSantis claim was “ science - based ” : the new law allows workers to ward off vaccination if they can propose their employer “ proof of natural resistance . ”

What this means in practice is not particularly clear – the police allege that it ’s up to the State Department ’s Department of Health to “ establish standards for competent aesculapian evidence that the employee has immunity to COVID-19 . ” Testing for resistance using scientific methods isnotoriously difficult – but contribute that aver Department of Health is take by surgeon oecumenical Joseph Ladapo , the controversial doctor known for spreadinganti - vaccine misinformationand tout thesupposed benefitsof COVID-19 infection , it ’s likely that a anterior infection will be all it takes to duck the authorization .

DeSantis is n’t the only politician seeking to cast “ natural granting immunity ” as a pandemic panacea : in late September , a group of 15 Republican doctor , dentists , and pharmacists in Congress sent awidely - criticized letterto the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention ( CDC ) urging them to take immunity gained from prior contagion into write up when set vaccine policies . More latterly , President Jair Bolsonaro of Brazil used the same estimation toonce againavoid taking his practice of medicine , declaring his “ resistance level … through the roof ” thanks to a late infection .

Here ’s the trouble .

“ Natural granting immunity ” is certainly a matter , but it ’s highly unpredictable . The amount of protective cover gain from a prior infection can vary depending on many thing : how disgusted you catch , how long ago it was , and which particular var. you happen to contract .

“ [ M]ost of the people who were infect in 2020 , and all the way through until the heart of 2021 were infected with earlier random variable of the coronavirus , ” Johns Hopkins epidemiologist Chris Beyrer toldCNBC Make It .

“ It may be that you had coronavirus last year and you feel like , therefore I do n’t want a vaccinum , ” he explained . “ But that rude immunity is improbable to protect you against Delta . ”

More than that , experts widely agree “ natural granting immunity ” simply is n’t that good compared to vaccination . A late CDC study found that people relying on a prior COVID-19 infection to protect them werefive times more likelyto finish up hospitalized with COVID-19 symptom than those who got vaccinated . On the other hand , those who survived COVID-19 and then got inoculate have been observe to develop “ intercrossed immunity ” – a super - potent exemption , capable of mounting antibody levels100 times higherthan infection alone .

Despitenearly two - thirdsof Americans being in favor of vaccine mandate , they have been met with hostility by Republican lawmakers across the country . Like Florida , Utah recently signed into law of nature an exemption from inoculation mandate for those with premature COVID-19 transmission , with GOP pol in New Hampshire and Idahosignaling their intentionsto follow suit .

Along with vaccine mandates , Florida ’s new lawprohibitsmask authorisation in school and quarantine students exposed to COVID-19 . The DoS is already one of the 26suing the White Houseover the Union vaccine mandate , and DeSantis announce last week that Florida would be joining another lawsuit drive to bar vaccine mandates on healthcare worker .

“ Many nurses could lose their chore , ” DeSantis said of the mandate . “ So you ’re actually making the hospital short - staff as a result of the authorisation . ”

“ So how does this , ” — he said , referring to the act of removing the peoplemost potential to spreada pestilent infection from a situation full of peoplemost likely to die of it —   “ make any sense ? ”